THE FACIAL PLASTIC SURGERY PODCAST
Ep. 2 – Face Two: Blepharoplasty
In this episode of The Facial Plastic Surgery Podcast, two specialist plastic surgeons discuss upper and lower eyelid surgery, including the anatomical changes that influence the appearance and function of the eyes. They explore different approaches to blepharoplasty and explain why assessment of the brow, eyelids and surrounding facial structures is important when considering surgical options.
The conversation also covers fat preservation and repositioning, facial fat grafting, temporal and sub-brow lifts, and the relationship between the lower eyelids and midface. The surgeons discuss potential complications, including dry eyes, chemosis and lower eyelid retraction, as well as the importance of tailoring treatment to individual anatomy.
In This Episode
- Upper blepharoplasty and excess eyelid skin
- The relationship between brow position and upper eyelid hooding
- Temporal lifts and sub-brow blepharoplasty
- Fat preservation, repositioning and grafting
- Lower blepharoplasty and the tear trough
- The relationship between the lower eyelids and midface
- Surgical risks, complications and revision procedures
- Individual anatomy and treatment planning
David: Welcome to the Facial Plastic Surgery Podcast. Two specialist plastic surgeons giving you the anatomy-based truth behind facial aesthetic surgery without the social media marketing spin. This podcast is general medical education, not specialist medical advice and should be taken as such. Always seek specialist advice from a FRACS-trained plastic surgeon or appropriately qualified FRACS surgeon specializing in facial aesthetic surgery. Welcome back, mate.
Phaethon: Back in Sydney. Last time we said we might continue with eyes, so that sounds reasonable.
David: We could take a top-down approach, starting with the brow, then upper and lower eyelids. Perhaps we should leave brow lifts for another episode and focus on the eyelids today.
Phaethon: That makes sense. We can cover upper and lower eyelids, as well as some less common approaches, such as sub-brow lifts.
David: well, you’ve you’ve done some of those. So yeah, that’ll be interesting to talk about that actually.
Phaethon: Laser, laser again.
David: Laser. So I
Phaethon: think there’s probably a role for laser blephs for some people. And maybe complications because people.
David: I think it’s important to talk about that, and also frames the idea a bit for people. In
Phaethon: fact, there was that patient recently that’s come back from overseas that had a really bad chemosis. Did you see that on Instagram?
David: No.
Phaethon: There was this poor lady that had her surgery overseas. and just had this. In fact, it was your neck of the woods. She was either Brisbane or Gold Coast And she like the chemosis was half her eye. She went overseas over 10 surgery
David: and then had a complication, and then had to go to Gold Coast, which is hospital, which is something not infrequently seen from tourist based cosmetic surgery, not infrequently seen to other countries throughout Asia and elsewhere. Well, we can just talk through talk through eyelid management and some of the issues that you can see with upper eyelids. So why don’t we’ll start talking about upper blepharoplasty? So I think upper eyelid reduction surgery is one of those surgeries which is for a lot of patients, especially older patients that I see on the coast, it generates a significant functional benefit for them. They often have dermatochalasis, which is an excess of the skin of the upper eyelid, which is redundant. It hangs over the ciliary margin, which is where your eyelashes are, and that drapes over your upper eyelid and blocks your vision, and so upper eyelid reduction for those patients. It’s a very rewarding procedure from that point of view because you are not only reducing the skin and rejuvenating the appearance of the upper eyelid, but also they can see again. I’ve been telling my dad to get this operation. actually, I’ve been telling. no, I’ve been telling. I’ve been telling. like all of a sudden, like I’ve been telling my dad to get this operation for a while because he complains about when he’s playing golf, if he’s looking up after he’s taken his shot
Phaethon: when he shanks it left or right, he can’t see. He can’t see because his eyelids
David: are sitting over the top. The
Phaethon: lateral hooding’s the problem, exactly. if it hits straight, if you hit straight, it’s okay. yeah, that’s right.
David: And like from a functional point of view, he’s going to get a vision benefit from having that surgery. So, I think in that setting, it’s it’s obviously fantastic. But the other side of things is that, some patients will have excess fat volume inside their orbit, which is post-septal, so behind the septum. If we think about, you’ve got the skin, you’ve got the muscle, then you’ve got the septum, then you’ve got the the levat, the levator, which lifts up the eyelid, and then you’ve got fat and other structures that are within side the orbit, like the globe, the muscles that move the globe into different directions, all that thing. But at the same time, in patients as you age, some of that septum attenuates a little bit, and you get a bulging of some of that fat. And that fat can be reduced in an upper blepharoplasty. So not only are you rejuvenating the eyelid appearance by excising some of that skin, you’re also addressing some of that fat, which sometimes be asymmetrical. So sometimes fat on the right might be larger than it is on the left. So you have to take out a larger amount of fat on the right. That involves a small release of the septum through the muscle, in through the septum, and then taking that fat out and tightening that skin. In my approach to upper bleph, I don’t cut out any muscle. That’s my personal preference. The data from. my own research into that, and also with various facial plastics focused surgeons in the U.S. and Canada, their approach is really for the most part not to take any muscle, and that’s because you get lower rates of chemosis by not taking the muscle, and also less dry eye related to not taking as much muscle, and I think the I think the data’s out there for that to support it as well. What about you? What’s your approach to upper bleph?
Phaethon: I mean, I just tend to make muscle because it’s a bit old school. Like, as far as I’m concerned, there’s no muscle excess. They didn’t grow more muscle. So I don’t know why you’d have to take it.
David: So similar to, I mean, we were talking earlier today about this, and that was that you were talking about how when you do an upper bleph, you do like to use the monopolar cautery. So this is electrical conduction, which causes a little bit of burning, right? And it burns the tissue. It cinches it together, and you use that at the lid margin. Sorry, not at the lid margin, at the at the crease, at the crease margin to generate a more prominent crease for patients when you do your suture closure. The classical teaching, I guess, or the old school teaching, like you say for upper blepharoplasty, was that by resecting a small portion of that muscle, you are optimizing that crease as well, and that was why it became something that, was done. I guess it was also easier to create a plane between the skin, the muscle, and the septum. So, skin and muscle as a unit, and the septum, that plane was easier to create than it was to separate the skin from technically
Phaethon: harder to take the technically harder.
David: It’s slower and harder, and more technically demanding to take the skin off. But in saying that, the demand between skin muscle and skin only is not dramatically different. I would say.
Phaethon: I mean, my big thing that I’ve had recently with blephs or upper blephs.
David: is
Phaethon: do you need an upper bleph or do you need a brow? and I think oftentimes we find that it’s that lateral. I’ve got it. My medial brow goes straight, and then I get this big drop off. So if I pull up my lateral brow, it fixes my hooding. Then the problem is a brow procedure is a lot more to embark on than a bleph. So a blef’s quite an easy procedure to do. You can do in the office. It’s quick.
David: Yes. Well, but it potentially a bit of not as simple as that. I guess. For instance, if you had somebody with fat excess in their medial orbit, as a bulge adjacent to where their upper eyelid excess was, you couldn’t do that operation in the rooms. Well
Phaethon: you have to be very careful. I’m not sure that the
David: no
Phaethon: really
David: not allowed to has to be an accredited facility.
Phaethon: So can’t
David: take that.
Phaethon: So I thought that
David: I was told this by Mark.
Phaethon: I I was as well. And then if you have a look, the position paper they put out, they left off brethren. So blepharoplasty. So you can still take. We can do lowers.
David: You can do lowers. in the rooms. Well, I know.
Phaethon: No, no. I’m saying it’s a good idea. No, I wouldn’t do it. But like, I think on fellowship, I saw
David: lowers being done. Well, fat transposition with full, yeah, septal reset being done under local anesthetic.
Phaethon: I’m a bit
David: sniffer sedation involved.
Phaethon: I think some of the stuff we’re very regulated here. and I think it’s great for patient safety. I think it’s really bad in terms of how much it’s pushing patients overseas. because I think if you’ve got a specialist plastic surgeon and a specialist anesthetist in an environment that is safe, someone has made sure there’s an emergency trolley, there’s a proper anesthetic machine. I don’t think that giving sedation in a good setup in your office for a small procedure like upper blephs
David: is
Phaethon: unsafe. And I think if you’re charging double the price. So for me, doing a blef in the office is exactly the same price surgeon fee as doing a bleph in hospital. but it’s double the cost to the patient.
David: that’s
Phaethon: huge. That’s more than flights to Thailand. yeah. More than a week in a hotel to Thailand. So why would you, why would you do it?
David: well, the thing is, you don’t want to come back, and you have asymmetries, you have scars, you have chemosis, you have permanent dry eyes, you have, all these other deformities or issues from having surgery done overseas by a surgeon that hasn’t done, thorough and complete plastic surgery training, but with the Frax qualifications. You
Phaethon: went overseas to learn from these surgeons
David: not in Thailand.
Phaethon: No, no, but
David: or Asia.
Phaethon: But I can fly to Belgium and have some procedures. You can
David: but it’s a different regulatory environment. Sure
Phaethon: that’s true.
David: The regulatory environment we’re in. But the guys you were seeing were
Phaethon: doing procedures in their office. in Canada. In the U.S. but
David: with sedation, and they don’t have a neatness doing sedation. Of course, that’s what
Phaethon: I’m saying. We just don’t. We just don’t offer that here.
David: No, but it’s it’s it is a different. I mean, if talking about the whole regulatory,. Let’s
Phaethon: leave another episode. I agree. We should do something on that because yeah
David: we should. definitely worth talking about it, and that frames things for patients as well. They get a better idea about
Phaethon: what we’re we’re what we’re about to do, what we’re not.
David: and the the rules and all that stuff in place to protect them and also to protect surgeons as well. In terms of upper blepharoplasty, anything else you want to talk about there? What do you think about Foxey?
Phaethon: That’s stirring me up. So I, I’m a convert.
David: You’re a convert. Talk to me more about this. Talk to me more about this. Go on.
Phaethon: So I thought it was crazy, and anytime anyone mentioned fox eye, I was like, “What are you doing? Yes. But I think going, I think starting doing endoscopic brows, yeah, and then doing temporal lifts. and then just getting more and more into the lower orbit, the mid face. I don’t think it’s esthetically pleasing if people come out looking like that, but I certainly think that having an a symmetrical and even pull on your lateral brow. and lower lid. is actually
David: but that conjunctival show and that triangular whole. You can’t
Phaethon: tightrope. You can’t tightrope that. I think that and patients find that irritating because
David: they fully release the lateral canthus as part of that. Well
Phaethon: the intention is to yes, but the intention is to be able to get
David: that pull. You have to do
Phaethon: superiorly, right? Not to reposition it laterally.
David: No
Phaethon: but if you reposition it laterally, then it holds your lid off the globe. but then and that’s irritating. patients hate that. but from an aesthetic point of view, this is not restorative. No, it’s no, but this is beautification. This is beautiful.
David: beautification or if you altering
Phaethon: that’s altering
David: anatomy. Yes, altering, and I look. It’s like it’s like a deep neck reduction, right? Like you’re you’re you’re altering anatomy because somebody doesn’t like the way that particular thing looks, right? There’s obviously, a consent process. There’s a whole range of things to discuss, multiple consultations before these decisions are made with patients, but if they want something done and you can do it surgically in a safe way that protects them, and I’m talking from the context of a deep neck reduction, I don’t personally do fox eye from a deep neck reduction point of view. I think it’s got a lot of value and can really change, the aesthetic profile for a lot of patients without doing other work on them,. Some, some people might suggest doing, jaw lengthening procedures or other things. But there’s all sorts of problems you can do by doing some of those things, and they do have a very, highly valuable role. But it’s only, I think, in very specific situations, and that needs to be decided by somebody who’s doing a lot of orthogonality surgery anyway. Back to back to eyelids, back to fox eye. Sorry, no, the reason
Phaethon: I’m a convert is because I’ve had two patients that swung me, and both of them. All right, fox eye is probably dramatic because they definitely did not end up looking like they’ve come straight from Istanbul. but they both of them had two millimeters of scleral show inferiorly. and they were young, like the one male sub 41, female sub 30.
David: Negative vector.
Phaethon: No, neither negative vector. but both had this just lower lid that looked in a puffy eyes, just looked tired, but from a lower eyelid, not an upper eyelid. Both came to me requesting a temporal lift. And we went around why they wanted it, what they were hoping to achieve. And both had these results that really changed the way their face looked in a positive way. hadn’t really sat well with me beforehand. But looking at their six-week results, I was really pleased. and now I’m happy to offer that as a procedure. I don’t call it fox eye because I think people that
David: what do you call
Phaethon: it? I’d say a temporal lift or endoscopic brow, ponytail, if they want more. And you have a conversation
David: with them a bit closer to that particular technique. Well, it’s just it’s super specific. Do you want like when I do this procedure, I can get this result.
Phaethon: and I I even I’ve offered other people like, I I want to move my eye, but I don’t want to move my brow, or I want to move my mid face and eye but not my brow. and I don’t think I like those results as much.
David: okay, like
Phaethon: I think trying to move a mid face and a lower lid, yeah, but not move the brow, you get bunching. Trying to move the eye and the lower lid for sure. it’s just I think
David: it’s all the same. But if
Phaethon: it’s all proportionate, then so I stick to ponytail temporal lift as nomenclature.
David: Yep. But
Phaethon: end of the day, you’re making a cut up here. and you’re putting some cable sutures or some fixation to lift the brow. but the reason the blepharopoulos comes into it is because I think those it obviates the need for a lot of those patients to have a bleph. because you’re repositioning this area. and you’re taking up the excess.
David: On that note, I see you’ve done a couple of sub-brow blephs, right?
Phaethon: that’s a different indication. So, because it’s really big in Asia. So, what Dave’s talking about is a cut under the eyebrow here, rather than in the crease here, and it’s to get rid of this. But it only, in my hands, it only works if your brow is fairly straight, because otherwise you’re going to kick it down. and I actually suspend orbicularis up onto the rim. so that it definitely doesn’t pull the brow down; it only pulls it up. but it’s great if they’ve got a crease they like. if they’ve got that lateral fullness, and I don’t know, do you stop your upper bluffs at the rim?
David: Not necessarily. I just sometimes, well, in some cases, I’ll go beyond the rim and go a little. I kick it up a little bit sometimes. I just find any time I go
Phaethon: over the rim, yeah, the scar is different, yeah, and not as nice as if I. I think in females
David: it’s well hidden, and especially if they’re of appropriate age, because the wrinkling in that region is almost completely imperceptible with the scar. But you’re right, like in younger patients where they don’t have that prominent peri orbital wrinkling. You don’t have anywhere to hide it. So in those situations, I mean, you still got the super tarsal crease, right?
Phaethon: But that doesn’t kick over past the rim.
David: No, it doesn’t. No, it doesn’t. But like if to hide what I’m saying, you’re to hide the majority of the scar at least. So no, this part of the
Phaethon: scars are mate. Like, yeah, it’s
David: always excellent the scar. But yeah, you’re right. it does have a. it sounds like it’s obviously got a role there.
Phaethon: I’ve started offering that. Now, and I think the results are solid. If your expectation is just lateral. Yes. It does not treat anything immediately. So once we go into that territory you’re talking about of having fat herniation, that’s right. So you
David: you can’t have fat maniation for that procedure. That fat in the the retroubbicularis fat that sits in that position. Do you reduce that as part of that lift, or are you are you just excising skin and doing almost like a skin only sub brow lift, or are you doing fat reduction with it? It
Phaethon: depends because if they’ve got essentially skin only, yeah. Because what’s what’s there is your lacrimal gland. If you’ve got
David: if you’ve got fullness though, if you’ve got
Phaethon: fullness that is pushing out from under the rim, yeah. You probably need your lacrimal gland resuspended. Through an old school bleph approach. if I thought that was the case pre-op, I’d probably elect to do a traditional blepharoposti, and then just hitch the gland up during my bleph. but for these patients, it’s more skin and subcutaneous fat, and then redraping excess where you can just take the scar further laterally. but for me at the moment it is good eyebrows. and hopefully eyebrow tattoos. and the way I see it is, if you get a bad scar. then you can always tattoo it, and then you don’t have a visible scar anywhere. I think that space is going to increase. I’ve seen a lot of it coming in from Southeast Asia.
David: I think you’re right. I think there’s probably going to be a bit more interest in that area for sure. when I think about sub, you’re talking about fullness laterally. with the lacrimal gland and ptosis of the gland and resuspension. also just prompted me to think about hollowing in the orbit, in the superior orbit, and I, in selected patients will fat graft that area with a small amount of fat. Often, you do not need more than one mil of fat in that region. Often, it’s less than that. But I think that can be quite powerful. And patients, I’ve had patients come in, see me in the clinic looking for an upper blepharoplasty because they think they’ve got excess skin. They’ve actually just got hollowing, and the skin excess is just a perception thing from their point of view. Once you fill out that deflated volume that’s in that sub-brow region for that patient, you actually you don’t even need to do a blepharoplasty in certain circumstances, but often a small amount of skin can help and be quite powerful. But putting that fat in that region can be, very rejuvenating to the upper eyelid appearance.
Phaethon: I completely agree. Actually, I haven’t grafted anyone’s upper eyelid yet. but that was only because I changed my upper eyelid. Procedure now, to redraping that medial fat. So I don’t cut out the medial fat I make a tunnel under or bick, and I I pull that medial fat into the middle So effectively, I’m, except what we do with the lower lids, redraping over the rim. I just take it out from there, put so I’m pushing it back up that A-frame deformity. And that was something that Chiara Botti does in Italy, and I just really liked the technique. It made sense to me. You’re just restoring. you’ve got that hollowing that way. Why you’re taking out here and grafting here? But I haven’t had a patient that I haven’t done a bleph on to then just graft the suborbital rim grafting. Was so good.
David: I’ve only done it in facelift patients to date, and that’s because I’m taking fat graft anyway. So I’m already, I’ve already got it there. It’s I’ve processed it in the centrifuge, and I’m, it’s ready to go. Certainly, it’s very powerful. I think it’s very powerful. for sure, especially for that Halloween. It’s just, it just, it can really and just
Phaethon: rejuvenating, like very rejuvenating
David: 100%
Phaethon: Yeah. Centrifuging, Talk to me about that.
David: Fat graft, I think, is this there’s this area of plastic surgery where you’re taking tissue from somewhere else and you want to put it into another location and you want as much of that tissue that you’re transferring to survive and it’s taking up a blood supply in a different location. So a lot of things you can do to optimize that. And when we think about blood supply, we think about I had I did I’ve done a PhD in tissue engineering, and part of that PhD was looking at scaffold based vascularization. So it’s like a essentially like 3d printed scaffold of effectively bone. It’s like a bone scaffold made of polycaprolactone and tricalcium phosphate. But what it is like the matrix, I guess the bony matrix that you would have if you had no cells and other mineralized bone taken away. You just had the scaffold in place with some mineralisation throughout, that’s what that was. But when you have tissue growing into that, the blood supply distance from where the scaffold is placed to where the blood vessels grow into that scaffold from the external surface is about for things to survive immediately is about 600 micrometers, right? So if you think about the diameter, just
Phaethon: over half a mil
David: just over half a millimeter, yeah. And if you’ve got a fat globule that you put into a particular location and you want it to survive, I think it’s particularly important for the face using graft that has a diameter which is no more than 1200 micrometers, so 1.2 mils, so 600 micrometers to get to that and vascularize the whole piece, right? So when I’m harvesting my fat, I harvest typically because it it shortens the time and the amount of volume you can get is greater. So I use a 20 402.4 millimeter lumen size and fenestration size on the actual cannula piece. I harvest that fat with a 10 mil Luolog syringe, and I harvest that typically from the belly or the thighs, and then I’ll process
Phaethon: by hand.
David: By hand, yeah. So not using
Phaethon: power assisted suction.
David: power assisted suction, which can traumatize the fat cells. And then once I have that fat, I’ll then get the fat and put it into little canisters that go into the centrifuge. Now the safest protocol to separate the plasma, the fat from the oil is 1200 RPM, three minutes, 400 grams, and so when you roll through at that at that rate, you’re unlikely to damage the fat cells when they’re spinning and separating. But at the same time, you do want them to effectively be separated, right? So that you can just get the good stuff, and the good stuff is, the gold fat, right? And once I’ve got that, it’s still 2400 in size, right? 2.4 millimeters. So then, then I use an atomizer. I shred it down to 1200. I don’t use it first because the reason I don’t use it first is because I don’t want I don’t want to lose some of the stromal vascular component to the centrifuge when it gets spun down. I want to keep some of that stromal vascular fraction, which is mesenchymal stem cells and all the other bits and pieces, which are great. Then getting that one mil syringes, and I use a
Phaethon: atodonize it, and then you
David: and then I use a one millimeter, 1.2 millimeter cannula, and that is used because you don’t get any barotrauma. So if you think about, you’ve got like a lumen in like a stainless steel external surface internal lumen. This thing is not dilating when you put a fat cell through it. So if you put a 22.4 millimeter fat through a 1.2 millimeter lumen, you’re going to destroy that fat cell, right? So that’s why it’s so important to use a similar. Cannula that you’re putting fat through, and like then you’re making really tiny stab incisions in particular locations that are hidden away. I use typically when I’m doing lower eyelid facial fat grafting, it’s usually lateral through the incision I’ve already made for a lower bleph or an upper bleph, and then I also make an incision just adjacent to the ALA, and then I’m putting my fingers on the orbital rim to make sure I’m not going to anywhere I don’t need to be, and then essentially filling up that region, for a lob left as an example. But using fat, I think, in a very targeted way, and having a specific protocol in mind and using it and seeing those results and and consistently reviewing them, I think, is an important way of doing fat grafting because if there are differences or changes associated with the results that you’re getting, you need to modify those, and you should be constantly reviewing. I think some different processes, especially fat grafting, I think, just to make sure you get the best possible results for your patients.
Phaethon: I think we’re a bit lucky in the face, just because probably get good blood supply, and yeah, I know you, and I haven’t had many problems with take in low volume faces.
David: Low volume. I look, I I’ve not really had problems with take, but I tell patients that minimum 50% is not going to survive, right? That’s that’s generally the this is
Phaethon: what we tell patients, but I don’t know. I reckon the survival’s better, like anecdotally. but you see at conferences, people talking about putting like 600 cc’s in a butt cheek. I don’t understand through like what you’ve been saying. If it gets 600 microns, 600 microns, and they’re getting like huge syringes, but they seem to something that we don’t really know.
David: I think there’s also the plane and also the location that you’re putting the fat, right? So if you, it’s like you stitch a graft in. If you have a large macro piece of graft, say three mil size or something like that, and you’ve harvested it and you’ve not shredded it through an atomizer, and then you’re putting that graft into a particular location, it may survive with inosculation, right? And if you’re putting it into a really well vascularized wound bed, like when they talk about BBLs, like Brazilian butt lifts
Phaethon: again
David: or in the rectus abdominis when they’re doing that, some people do this like really ultra refined abdominal appearance where they want to, put they contour they liposac regions each
Phaethon: ab
David: each ab, and then they put fat in the muscle as well to augment that shape. I think in that situation, it’s a different graft bed to the one we’re using typically in the face. I mean, we might put it subperiosteal, we might put it in the subcutaneous region in certain areas, it’s variable, based on where you’re deciding to put it. piriform space.
Phaethon: I read a recent study about that with the fat crafting intramuscularly, but I think it was out of Portugal. and they actually had increased strength outcomes.
David: Someone was telling me about this actually as well. yeah.
Phaethon: You don’t do intramuscular fat
David: no, do
Phaethon: you? I do not.
David: Do you?
Phaethon: Plenty of Gold Coast trip
David: no? No, no, no.
Phaethon: Just improve my bench press.
David: that’s it. In and the yeah ab workouts and all. It’d be interesting
Phaethon: to it. I mean, it’s not something in the face that we would see, but
David: it’s an interesting concept. I mean, BBL’s obviously got a pretty bad name historically, and it’s a very massive death
Phaethon: rate
David: huge death rate. Cosmetic procedure causing deaths is
Phaethon: well, I think now really
David: hectic
Phaethon: first lord countries. It’s very taboo almost to do it without ultrasound guidance.
David: I think so, and doing it in someone highly experienced with that ultrasound guidance and approach and that thing. It’s not a procedure that I personally offer at all, and I’m not aware of anyone on the Gold Coast that does it, or actually even in Brisbane, as far as I know. Sydney is anyone doing it in Sydney?
Phaethon: I don’t know if anyone offers a BBL. I’ve definitely seen people fat grafting the hip dips and things like that. But I’m not sure that concept of 600, 800 mil augments is happening, or maybe it’s just not happening by people I know. I’ve definitely seen patients come back from overseas with over half a liter per side, which is pretty impressive that they can take that volume and get it in there.
David: But
Phaethon: the complications I’ve seen are pretty horrific.
David: I mean, horrendous pressure
Phaethon: pressure, infection, all
David: sorts of things
Phaethon: leaking. Anyway, back to blood.
David: Back to eyelids. Yeah
Phaethon: yeah. Distracted. So, upper lip. I was talking about taking out skin, probably not muscle.
David: Yep. We
Phaethon: both take medial fat if you need
David: it. I don’t really touch central. I don’t really touch central fat at all. And then yeah, volumize. I will fat graft the fat sub-brow area.
Phaethon: I think patients would find it quite interesting looking at the, when you see a picture of the different lacquer mo gland, the medial fat. And the middle fat, yeah, And I’m always telling other registrars or people like, yeah, that medial fat looks like pineapple, and the middle fat is like mango. And if you make a cut and look at them, they’re very different yellows. like completely different.
David: Yeah. Has anyone ever actually looked at the
Phaethon: why?
David: the histology. Maybe that’s a hit. That’s only just a paper
Phaethon: for it. No, so I think I wonder
David: why that
Phaethon: is. They’re both look it up. They’re both retroceptile.
David: well, both retroceptal fat, but and
Phaethon: they’re both pretty vascular. So I don’t know. That’s
David: yeah. It’s
Phaethon: not. It’s not like staining from blood. I think the lipid is the color. Yeah
David: yeah. In terms of lower eyelids
Phaethon: lowest. And do you do anything for anything else for uppers
David: in selected patients who’ve got unilateral ptosis? typically as a second procedure, I’ll do a levator advancement. I don’t really
Phaethon: do ptosis repairs. levator advancement.
David: mularectomy if it’s a very mild ptosis, but with a true ptosis, moderate, level of descent of the upper eyelid, especially with unilateral asymmetry. I will do a levator advancement.
Phaethon: Yeah. And do you do I’m awake?
David: awake with local anesthetic. I do it separately so that I can control that. So
Phaethon: you can actually yeah. Nice.
David: In terms of lower eyelids, now there’s a lot to unpack.
Phaethon: Massive topic.
David: big topic. But if we were, do you want to just explain lower eyelid aging and lower eyelid anatomy to the audience?
Phaethon: I think so. All right. What I tell my patients is your lower eyelid aesthetic is comprised of three separate areas. I say the lower lid itself, and the lower lid is effectively made by the shape created from the septum, which is a structure from your bone to your lashes, and then over age that bows, much like you’re talking about the upper lids, with fat pushing at it from the inside. So you get septal attenuation and bowing outwards, and that can give us our first hollow wrinkle line.
David: like
Phaethon: like like yeah. Then you’ve got the trough. So the trough is the ligaments that are going from the bone onto the muscle underneath. So your orbicularis retaining ligament. Or your zygomatic ligament. we call them different things, but there is attachments that attach the bone to the skin or the muscle underneath, and that gives us a shelf, and then under that you’ve got your malar fat, but your malar fat itself moves. So I explain this as it’s one homogenous mass to start with, where you don’t have a lead cheek junction, but it’s hard to know when one is bulging out or one is sliding down, and that trough becomes apparent. So we have multiple bulges. But is that because your mid face is descended? Is that because your eyelids bulged out. Is that both? That’s what is difficult to see, and that’s what using filler tries to efface by just adding volume when you don’t necessarily need more volume. You need the anatomy restored. So I have not gone or
David: anatomy altered
Phaethon: altered. but so there’s people that restore it now. I’ve seen people.
David: So they’ll fat graft. Well, I’ve
Phaethon: seen people touting septal resets. to tighten the septum. like intraorbital septal reset, which I haven’t toyed with, but I’ve started to do less lower eyelid and think about it more as a: what do I need to do to revolumise the mailer? whether that be a ponytail, whether that be a traditional deep plane facelift
David: because extending that to the mid face, extending that right to the mid face, yeah, yeah.
Phaethon: Because if we can volumize that tear trough, adequately, Potentially, we don’t need to enter the orbit, play around with the fat, But if you separately have a very distorted lower lid septum
David: then
Phaethon: yes, taking that fat out very appropriate, Or like I know you do the same with the actually disrupting the IRL and then redraping the fat over, yeah, which then stops it sticking down, volumizing this, it’s a great operation. It is
David: a great operation. Actually, quite enjoy that operation. It’s yeah, quite a satisfying operation. I learnt my approach to lower eyelid. Juvination from Rick Warren, who’s a plastic surgeon in Vancouver. he’s got a very nuanced approach. He’s been doing transcutaneous lobe blepharoplasty for many years now. Gets very good, very consistent results. Absolutely. So he makes a subciliary incision. He raises a skin flap only. Doesn’t take orbicularis as part of that flap, he then makes an incision
Phaethon: skin only, skin only, not skin muscle
David: no, just skin only, and then makes an incision through the orbicularis, which is about it works out to be about a centimeter in length, so only a small incision through the total length of the orbicularis, and it’s done within the fibers. He does it at a particular point, which is about eight millimeters below the ciliary margin, and at the mid-pupillary line, and he finds that you get it’s
Phaethon: very central, very
David: central. He finds that you get this nerve branch that runs up. He sweeps it to the side and then retracts it, doesn’t divide it. It’s a very tiny little nerve branch. You then have your assistant retract the orbicularis. You use a Q-tip to dissect down onto the rim in the anterior, like anterior to the septal, and into the anterior to the septet. So you’re in front of the septum, you’re under the muscle, get down onto the rim, and then release that orbital retaining ligament
Phaethon: the
David: orbicularis retaining ligament, just completely release it, and a bit of medial orbicularis as well. Then fenestration, so medial fat pads. You make a little three
Phaethon: fenestrations. Two
David: fenestrations through that. One through the medial fat pad. One through the central. Two bits of fat pulled out through the central one onto the rim. Both stitched with proline down onto the superior aspect of the magzilla. Just where the rim is there.
Phaethon: Are you doing pledgeets?
David: No pledgets. So just 6o proline. You pull it over, put it down in the space, and same with the medial down in the space over the rim. So you’re suturing it and obliterating, and you feel the rim and you can feel the yeah, softened it. You just need to do it in a homogenous way so that you don’t have bombs or steps, and then resect a little bit of the lateral fat pad after pressing down just gently on the globe to see the position and volume that you have left remaining, and often just resecting a small amount of fat laterally in that lateral fat pad just gives you so
Phaethon: transposing middle and medial, but not lateral. That’s right. yeah. I mean, this is more where you’re hollow, right? Yeah. Yeah. Exactly.
David: So, and I think that obliterates the hollowing and all that thing that people get, and that the bulge, that lid-cheek junction, valley that people will get. It’s quite powerful for doing that. The other side of things is that obviously in certain patients, there’s lots of risks associated with doing a lot of blepharoplasty, especially transcutaneous issues with retractors, issues with ectropion, issues with dry eye, chemosis, all sorts of things. things that I do to try and avoid complications, in particular ectropion, is to for a lot of patients, patients in this group that I typically see older patients, what I will do is a 5o PDS double armed that I go through the through the fornix there and take the inferior limbus of the lateral canthus. I take the lateral the extension of the lateral canthus on the inferior aspect, and then I pull it up and I do a fixation to the periosteum and the in the superior orbiter, in the superior orbit, there just at the upper rim, and that really repositions the vector of the lower eyelid, but also provides a lot of support. Once I’ve done that, I then cut off any additional skin that I need to excise to, make sure that I’m not taking out too much skin, because I think that’s the issue that you can get is if you’re taking out too much skin.
Phaethon: Canthopexy first.
David: Canthopexy before cutting. Gentle, gentle skin reception. Gentle skin resection. I mean that’s my that’s my approach so far working out really good. But I think in association with lower blephs, I think if you’ve got mid face deficiency, I you were talking before about Vipala and Tonard, wanting fat graft, different things, and yeah
Phaethon: they just they just they
David: fat graft the lower eyelid, right? That’s the. But I think I think doing a fat trans position lower blepharoplasty alongside fat grafting
Phaethon: to
David: fill up the mid face in that setting is also quite a powerful thing to do because you can’t restore that mid face volume if they do have deficiency.
Phaethon: Their rationale for doing that procedure was why introduce the risk of disrupting the septum when you can go intraocular only, retroceptal, pick out the fat that you don’t want there. And then fat graft, and then you haven’t disrupted your middle lamella. You don’t get the host of problems that you potentially create. At the risk of what I suppose they would say that you can very accurately fat graft, and. I suppose the transposers would say, “Well, you’re guaranteed it to take if you’re transposing a flap. I don’t know. It’s pretty hard to transpose fat globules perfectly even.
David: It is. I think. I think. Look, I think with a bit of fat, a sprinkle, sprinkle of fat graft alongside a lower blepharoplasty fat transposition, whether that’s transcutaneous or transconjunctivable, is pretty good. But I guess the approach of releasing the arcus in a transconjunctival approach with a pledgeet or some bolster on the external surface, you can drape it underneath that periosteum layer, and then you doesn’t the bumps don’t matter. That’s in the that’s in a trans conjunctival approach. The bumps don’t matter as much because it’s so far deeper than everything else that the periosteum smooths that out for you. But in saying that, intuitively, the transcutaneous approach, I feel more comfortable doing that approach. I feel like I’ve got more control. Well, I think
Phaethon: from our recon background
David: we’re
Phaethon: used to doing fossil strips things like
David: for sure
Phaethon: cutting out skin cancers
David: absolutely, orbicularis revectoring. What do you think about
Phaethon: it? I’ve done it. I’m not sure that it’s any like my best results so far have been from photographing. yeah. From doing well, hold on, no, it’s been from facelifts. and then factcrafting. Yes. So at some point you’re-vectoring everything. of course. But then I’m not. I’m not cutting out a pizza slice and differentially vectoring the orbicularis. That’s why I harp back on that restore the midfacial volume. I do fat craft everyone here. I think no matter how good your lift is, I’m just not convinced that you can lift this vertically slash at all medially. So there’s always going to be a hollow here where you can’t get to. that I think is that’s that territory for me that fat grafting can only get to.
David: 100% That’s the tear trough. That medial
Phaethon: the most medial part of the trough
David: and for a lot of people, that’s a like a lifelong thing, right? The tear trough is just an anatomical variation of the lower eyelid, right? Some people have a deep one, some people don’t. It’s less obvious in certain demographics, so it’s it’s one of those things. And some people really don’t like it. Some people obviously like it. It gives them character. I feel like this is this is this blurred line discussion about what is a when we talk about cosmetic procedures being restorative or they’re not necessarily restorative they’re altering existing anatomy but they’re doing it for people that perceive these particular issues to be different, and they want them to be less noticeable to them in some way or another. It’s like rhinoplasty. Some people you look at their nose and be like, “You have a normal looking nose, but they may they may look at it and say, “This issue, I don’t, I don’t like this particular issue. I have too much, fullness at the super tip position. What can we do about it? Whatever, and you look at them, you go, okay, well, we can do this X, Y, Z. It’s
Phaethon: interesting now that you mention that restoration, because there’s recently been a lot in the media about guys getting bluffs and looking really weird. I don’t want to mention celebrity names, but and I’ve got a theory on that, and that’s about again, we are really good at doing blefs on females.
David: Bradley Cooper
Phaethon: but like we do female blefs, we don’t often do male lower lids as much, right, or at least not my practice
David: and
Phaethon: I think globally, facial esthetics has been the purview of females more.
David: I would agree with that, yeah, for sure.
Phaethon: So, a very youthful female face has no lead cheek junction. That just we just go straight up into a lid. I think that is what makes you look feminine. I think males typically have now. If you’ve got multiple grooves, or if you’ve got a line halfway through your lid, or you’ve got a really wide trough, that makes you look tired. but I think if your skin hugs your eye gently, there is a distinction between your distinction
David: between the two, and then
Phaethon: you’ve got a full cheek. that’s just masculine. but I I’ve got a sneaking suspicion that getting rid of that, so blading that with probably too much fat grafting, really, is what feminizes the masculine face. and I think it’s probably that extra volumization that we see in people that are overfilled, yeah. People that are overlifted. I’m gonna watch this space. I’m gonna have a. I’m gonna start playing around with that a bit more in different demographics.
David: I think the lower eyelid, rejuvenation, if you will, in males has a distinct role. The last podcast, I think we spoke about this very, very briefly, but I think it’s really important. Have photos of patients. Get them to bring in a previous photo when they were young. if you’ve got someone in their late 50s, get them to bring. What were you like at 25? Hey, what, what, and what, what are you hoping to achieve? And what things can we get to when we’re doing a procedure for you? Because if they’ve got a really prominent tear trough when they were 25, and they did have a lid cheek junction then, but still had a youthful appearing face, and they came to you and they wanted lower eyelid blepharoplasty.
Phaethon: You ablate it, and you ablate it, and
David: then they may not completely understand, and that they get something that they not don’t necessarily want. I think it’s a really valuable part of the consultation, especially in any facial aesthetic procedure. It gives a lot of information to patients just for themselves as to what they want. It makes it a bit clearer and makes your job clearer by default.
Phaethon: I think that certainly helps. And I mean, we are now entering the phase of getting. It gets more difficult for us because we have those patients, and it’s usually the like over 50s, over 60s that want rejuvenation. But now we’re getting all those under 40s, that don’t necessarily want to look younger. Well
David: this is the thing they want. They they want a different look. they want to change. It’s a change in the way that they appear from one aspect of their face or another. It’s not necessarily equally
Phaethon: as valid.
David: Equally as valid
Phaethon: but
David: equally as valid
Phaethon: more challenging for us. I think we are then trying to. I mean, the East Asians have done this for a long time with the double eyelid surgery. They’ve said, “Okay, this is classic. This is a look that I want to achieve. This
David: is very classic. But it’s
Phaethon: very different from your Afro Caribbean coming to you with a picture of, an Asian nose. Or Caucasian nose and saying, or brow, something that like structurally is very difficult to correct.
David: 100% and that’s like the whole fox eye thing, right? Well, exactly. This is the fox eye. This is the lip. Well
Phaethon: lip lift can go either way. complications of blephs because there’s probably one thing we didn’t touch on. well, we spoke
David: about it briefly, but lower less. So chemosis is a pretty classic one. you’re tightening structures around lower eyelids. the conjunctiva can swell, and you can get a lot of. So
Phaethon: for everyone else, let’s explain the conjunct. yeah.
David: So chemosis is effectively swelling of the soft tissues internal to the eyelids, right? It’s that it’s that peri-conjunctival tissue that then swells secondary to inflammation. and it’s post-operative. It’s it’s related to fluid that’s collecting in the area.
Phaethon: Looks like a little bit of yellow jelly growing on the white thing of your eye.
David: Exactly. Effectively, the way to usually you can manage that expectantly, and for a lot of patients, they just need a little bit of explanation, which they will have had in their, pre-operative consultation anyway. But obviously, explaining to them that this is a normal part of healing in certain situations, and it can take a couple of weeks to resolve. Sometimes it can take a little bit longer, and it also depends on how much and involved a dissection was laterally and all sorts of things because the lymphatic pathways can be affected and that can contribute to ongoing chemosis. So that’s one thing that can happen. Obviously, you’ll have a scar as a standard thing if it’s a transcutaneous lower blepharoplasty. If it’s a transconjunctival, so that means they’ve gone through the internal lower eyelid, mucosa through that conjunctiva that will leave a scar internally. A lot of surgeons will not suture that mucosa, that conjunctiva. Just leave it to heal on its own. It heals pretty fine without any problems. Some people will fix it. it doesn’t really change things dramatically. It depends on how they handle the fat in terms of some other issues that you can have: asymmetry, hollowing, all sorts of things. So if there’s a lot of fat that’s resected as part of a transcutaneous or transconjunctival lower blepharoplasty, then that can cause hollowing. And this was something I think historically, which was a pretty classic and conventional approach to lower bleph, was that just resect as much of that fat as you can to hollow it out, so that you’ve got a flat surface rolling into a flat surface, you don’t have the valley anymore. You’re basically just demolishing the mountain and demolishing the other mountain, while not demolishing the other mountain, just flattening one so that it levels out to the other. Now that approach generated like a sunken, hollowed appearance to the lower eyelid-it was no, not as aesthetic as. It gives
Phaethon: space for your eyes to fall back. Exactly.
David: So your eyes are cushioned by the–they’re surrounded by muscles that attach to the globe, and then surrounding them is fat, orbital fat, right? And it cushions the globe and the muscles. Taking away too much of that fat can cause the eye to sink back a little bit, but also it can create that hollowed, sunken in appearance to the eyes, and a way I think moving forward that attempted to address this particular issue was fat preservation, right? that’s where the yeah the redraping and transposition of the fat is and because of that, it’s. Probably taken over, I think, is the more conventional approach to managing lower eyelid. that’s no longer fat reposition. that’s very standard. It’s very conventional now. Whereas fat resections fallen out of favor, I think, for a lot of surgeons. Everything’s changed there in that regard. Ectropion. So ectropion, you may see there’s older patients walking around who’ve got ectropians, a senile ectropian. you see these patients walking around, and they’ve got a very lax lower lid, and they have essentially conjunctival exposure, and they get inflammation, they get redness irritation, and they’re not completely protecting their globe as well because it’s not being covered and lubricated like it normally would be. So, these sorts of things can happen after having a lower blepharoplasty if the procedure is done in a way that the lower lid is not resuspended and tight. So in a patient who’s already got CNALLOTRABION who wants a lower blepharoplasty in those patients, I’ll do a full canthoplasty with a drill hole. So I’ll drill holes into the bone up here and stabilize the lower lid to those using buried sutures under the skin and buried away, but it retightens this lower eyelid in a way that is quite robust and long lasting. Whereas for conventional patients who don’t have that senile ectropion, they’ve just got maybe some high risk features like a negative vector, which is essentially hollowing of the maxilla adjacent to where the lower eyelid sits. So the eye and the fat below it sit a little bit in front of where the magzilla is. In those patients, I’ll do acanthopexi which is effectively like what I explained before the suture that goes through the corner of the lower eyelid and then up and then basically tightens that
Phaethon: because that’s a really bad problem. That’s a really
David: it’s a it’s a massive problem, especially for a cosmetic procedure, right? And so obviously we we’re all doing things to prevent this from happening. Some surgeons use a frost suture for the first few days after doing a lower bleph, where they basically stitch the lower eyelid to the brow and like lift it up and resuspend it so that there’s no tension on the repair. So that’s another thing you can do. It’s a bit traumatic
Phaethon: for me. I don’t know if suturing people’s eyelids together. but that’s I. That’s still one of my indications for a subperiosteal facelift.
David: Yeah. So talk to me about that.
Phaethon: So something that I had learnt overseas in Belgium again because we were getting a few referrals for people that had previous blephs. Yeah. That had over a section. The solution was then actually moving the mound of the lower lid. But attached to the cheek. And just sliding the periosteum north. So massive dissection, a lot of swelling. but because you’re resetting the framework of that lower lid, up five mil, yeah, it allows then doing a canthopexy or something is very reasonable as a support suture. but your base is no longer pulling. So I’ve found that a really powerful operation. but it’s a big thing to be putting drill holes.
David: It’s a big thing. I, I was in Beverly Hills not long ago, and I spent a couple of days with Guy Masry, who knows, fantastic. the guy, the Oculoplastics guy. lovely guy, and was very happy to teach me and spend the time to show me some, some complicated cases that he was doing, and he was doing. he does a lot of lower eyelid revision work. I think it’s definitely a subspecialty interest for him. He gets a lot of those referrals because of his expertise, and he did a mid face lift for a patient with severe lower lid retraction, and did a palatal graft for the conjunctiva as well. Transcond. You did a
Phaethon: approach.
David: So transcond and then lateral canthal release. And then dissects down, gets the mid face, resuspends mid face, and then the gap that’s left between the lower free edge of the conjunctiva and the lid, he sutures the palatal graft to recreate that the middle and posterior lamella.
Phaethon: It’s very, I can aggressive. Obviously, it’s a bad problem.
David: Well, for these patients, obviously they’ve had procedures in the past, sometimes several procedures, and he’s he does these procedures as a obviously a revision last yeah he gets requests some people obviously asking for that mid face lift to as a cosmetic procedure, but he doesn’t like to do it as a cosmetic procedure because he thinks it’s more of a reconstructive procedure in the in the way that he does it. But I guess he sees the patience for that reconstructive indication in that way, and he’s got that approach that he uses for that, which is yeah. I recently
Phaethon: did one for a cosmetic indication
David: yeah. And how did it go?
Phaethon: I think it was good, But I think it’s subtle, and it’s a big operation.
David: What did you do with the lateral canthus?
Phaethon: Just a canthus, but. This was for rejuvenation, so mid face. Do
David: fat graft as well? yeah, okay. Yeah
Phaethon: fact grafting as well. But and I also went transoral. So I actually mobilized the whole mid face.
David: and then filled
Phaethon: drill holes in the orbital rim. So resuspended through. So it was quite an aggressive operation. In someone that I was trying not to feminize, So otherwise I would have done my ponytail, But I thought that now there was a lot of discussion about what’s going on around the eyes, And there was a very hard no, from the lateral pull of anything with her superior vector suspension, And so I think we met in the middle there, And good result, but subtle. I think for something like a ectropion repair, I think is definitely indicated. I’m not sure that if I was a patient, I’d put myself through mid face dissection. for what I think is a relatively small, subtle result.
David: I think you can achieve a lot with fat graft.
Phaethon: and
David: I think that what you can achieve with fat graft for these cosmetic patients looking for that mid face fullness and that medial cheek fullness. It in a lot of respects may obviate the need to do a mid face lift, and then well, if they’ve got up, it was
Phaethon: that nasolabial folds and the actual mobilization, which was what had to tip me. But yeah
David: what do you think about endoscopic approaches to that mid face component? Because you do that as well. That’s what I do. that standard. That was
Phaethon: what I prefer to do.
David: but in this particular case, you. Well, I
Phaethon: just don’t think I don’t think you can
David: get that much pull.
Phaethon: I think you’re always well. If you’re doing that, you have to do some net approach or a top down and lift it all as one vector. I think if you’re lifting mid face only and do this, then you end up with some weird bunching at the point where you stop. So unless you do everything, and if the patient doesn’t want everything then I’m not sure that the procedure is appropriate. so then you have to come. Your access point has to be different. But like you said, back to like tailoring it for the patient. We’ve done so much head and neck recon. We’ve done so many different aesthetic fellowships and seen different people’s approaches. You can change, pick and choose what might work for different people?
David: Certainly, having a broad training in both, Sydney and then Queensland, having a lot of head and neck exposure, doing head and neck surgery with a lot of eyelid reconstruction for at least two years before going on a craniofacial fellowship, and then additional training with, oculoplastic, surgeons as well as going and doing observerships with people like very brief observership with Doctor Massery, but only for a couple of days. But we did some really interesting cases. exactly. So like
Phaethon: high yield
David: high yield stuff. And so I think once you’ve got that training and you what to get out of these brief observerships elsewhere, and wherever you can really get a lot from them, and help translate some of that back to to your patients and get good results.
Phaethon: Well, I reckon we’ve got a little good little bit on blefs. Hopefully, we get a few comments and see what people would like a bit more information about specifically.
David: I think that’s a good thing. I think if people ask some questions about stuff that that they want us to talk about, we’ll eventually we’ll go back to eyelid
Phaethon: subreddits. yeah. So yeah, exactly. No, I think it’s good. We should, in fact, we should probably dedicate. like a slot. maybe once every few or something. This is Mandy from Griffith. that might be a good way to get a few bit of live, not live feedback, but I think
David: questions that are valuable and yeah for sure.
Phaethon: And let’s face it. If you have the question, someone else is going to have the same question
David: for sure. Absolutely
Phaethon: no one is. you’re sitting there by yourself at home thinking, like, “Oh, I’ve got this concern, and I keep my am I is it is it me? Is it a problem? But like, there’s another 1000 people wanting to know the answer. Now you can ask. So, guys, just to reiterate, this is a educational podcast only. This is not specialist medical advice for your particular situation. If you would like to take any further steps, please reach out to your GP if you’re in Australia and get a referral, and reach out to a specialist plastic surgeon or another fellowship trained specialist facial aesthetic surgeon, so you can go through what is appropriate for you.
This transcript has been AI-generated and may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please refer to the original podcast recording for the full discussion.
Explore the podcast
Ep. 3 – Face Three: Anaesthesia in Face Lift Surgery
An exploration of the different types of anaesthesia used in facelift surgery, including general anaesthesia, local anaesthetic and sedation.
Ep. 2 – Face Two: Blepharoplasty
An exploration of the different types of anaesthesia used in facelift surgery, including general anaesthesia, local anaesthetic and sedation.
Ep. 1 – Face One
An exploration of the different types of anaesthesia used in facelift surgery, including general anaesthesia, local anaesthetic and sedation.




